This article would deal with ethical issues
which do not come under the purview of legality but under morality. The aim of
this section is not to address the issues which are explicitly related to “good
v/s bad” or “right v/s wrong” at the individual level. However, the focus here
is to address the conflict situation between the individual values and the
values and duties assigned to the role of job to which she/he is incumbent to.
The ethical concern and dilemmas of this kind could be faced by any either working
in government or private institutions. The peculiar fact about civil services exam is that it
checks the ethics of the candidates as well these days.
In many cases the
civil servants are responsible for certain duties (those that
constitute the professional role), they sometimes believe they are obligated to
act otherwise. This occurs because civil servants, along with everyone else in
modern society, maintain an array of roles related to family, community, and
society, each carrying a set of obligations and vested with certain personal
interests. The quite common result is conflict among roles as these competing
forces push and pull in opposite directions. The effects of these conflicts are
compounded by the range of discretion administrators must exercise. The intent
of legislation is frequently stated in broad language, leaving the specifics about civil services. Consequently,
ethical standards and sensitivity are crucial to the responsible use of this
discretion.
The art of ethical civil services, of “doing
good while doing well” (Lawton 1998), is built upon yet another parallax: the
parallax of deontology and teleology. On the one hand, public servants,
administrators, and officials have a duty (and therefore obligations) to the
organizations in which they serve. On the other hand, that duty has a
teleological slant: to uphold and enhance the common good, however this may be
defined. Again let us appreciate that this is not a paradox, and these
positions need not be thought of as antagonistic, but as distinctly different
approaches to the same ethical issues. One of the most famous cases in recent
UK political history illustrates this situation admirably. These facts about group discussion have to be kept
in mind.
No comments:
Post a Comment